The Best Wedding Caterers in Bayport, NY

The Best Wedding Caterers in Bayport, NY

How do we sort results, including Sponsored Ads and personalized results?


76 Wedding Caterers in Bayport, NY

Quick responder
ITALIANA FOODS LLC 

5.0

  • Starts at $3,000
  • Serves Bayport, NY
  • Offer

Bring the taste of Italy to your wedding celebration with ITALIANA FOODS LLC, a New Rochelle, NY-based catering company specializing in handmade Italian dishes made with love. Founders Giusy and Lucia are the sixth generation of talented culinary creatives in their family. They are honored to share the incredible food traditions of their Italian hometown with couples and their loved ones throughout the Westchester area. In addition to their catering services, Italiana foods also offer a beautiful and Romantic Vintage APE Piaggio 1976 build Food Truck that adds a little fun and excitement to any occasion.

Awarded Best of Zola
I used Italiana Foods for my wife's surprise birthday and was blown away! The vintage Ape food truck created a great experience for our guests and the pizzas were amazing. The rest of the food we ordered was very authentic Italian, and really tasted great. We were very happy with the service, as the servers and team were very attentive to our needs. Italiana Foods made our event very enjoyable and I would definitely recommend them for anyone looking to book a high quality caterer.
Brian S., 9 months ago
GemHidden gem
Creative Courses Catering 

5.0

  • Starts at $2,400
  • Serves Bayport, NY

Owner Samy Sabil, formerly of the acclaimed North Fork Table and Inn of Southold, N.Y, has successfully operated his business based on the North Fork of Long Island for the past 20 years. Creative Courses Catering has delighted clients’ palates from the East End of Long Island to Manhattan, Miami, and L.A.

Creative courses was the best choice for my husband and I. Besides the food being the best we tasted throughout the process, Samy was amazing to have work with from our first email interaction until the day of the wedding.
Danielle, 6 months ago
Sunflowers Event Planning, Inc 

5.0

  • Serves Bayport, NY

With more then 25 years experience we find that listening to every bride and or client describe what they want for their special day or event is what it takes to be successful. It's what you want not what we want. Creativity is a strong characteristic and I enjoy the final product. It's simple. When the clients are happy I know we were to their expectations and that's all that matters at the end of the day.

We hired Sunflowers for our daughter's back yard wedding on Sept 12, 2020. Once Chef Laura and her crew arrived (hours before the event), they took over and I knew I was in good hands. Chef Laura was a pleasure to work with and also provided excellent guidance during the planning stages. The appetizers, passed during cocktail hour, looked and tasted great. All of the food during the buffet dinner was also excellent. The bar was well stocked with everything we needed for our crowd, which enjoys their cocktails. The crew were professional and responsive and kept everything clean during the party. Because of their hard work, I was able to enjoy the day! I will definitely call on Sunflowers for future events and would recommend them highly.
Rae, 5 years ago
Quick responder
Around The Fire 

5.0

  • Serves Bayport, NY

Around The Fire is a boutique Private Chef Catering service created by Adam Kelinson who has been serving the Hamptons for almost 20 years. My mission is to connect people with food, culture and nutrition through a diverse array of offerings that range from regular In-Home Meal Preparation to Amazing Events for weddings, private parties and dinners. As a Chef I offer a nutritional background that supports health, wellness and active lifestyles while our events specialize in Wood Fired Pizza and Open Fire Cooking.

Awarded Best of Zola
Our experience with Around the Fire was seamless from start to finish. Adam and his team truly love what they do and it shows. Adam worked with us to curate a menu for our child’s (adult friendly) birthday party and the execution of the event was flawless. He is fun to work with, understanding, and extremely professional. The food met all of our criteria- healthy, organic, local, and delicious. We highly recommend around the fire and will be booking more events with Adam and his team soon!
Josh and A., 6 years ago
Farm To Table Catering and Cafe by Filomena 

5.0

  • Starts at $50
  • Serves Bayport, NY

Farm to Table Catering by Filomena is a full-service catering company situated in Nesconset, NY. Farm to Table Catering by Filomena specializes in producing Farm to Table dishes using high-quality, local, and seasonal ingredients. Each appetizer, entrée, and buffet display is designed with flavor and visual appeal in mind. On your big day, Filomena can provide seasoned servers, bar and beverage packages, tables, chairs, linens, and more. During a consultation, Filomena takes your details, from color schemes to guest numbers, before designing a menu that complements your day in every way.

"Positive reviews help others feel confident about choosing us for their wedding or special event.
Scott B., 7 months ago
Quick responder
Platinum Party 

5.0

  • Serves Bayport, NY

Platinum Party Planners is a full-service catering and event planning company. Our events are completely customized, we guide our clients through the planning process of selecting and designing a menu to reflect our clients’ vision. In addition, we can help you plan and design your event by selecting your event color palette, centerpieces, décor pieces etcetera. We will also coordinate with the best preferred/recommended vendors for all necessary rentals like tents, table, and chair styles and much more!! We will get every detail right on your most important day! We're with you every step of the way to ensure a flawless event.

Awarded Best of Zola
Tracy, George, Jess, and the entire PPP team absolutely made our wedding dreams come true in every possible way! From the very beginning, we knew we were in the best of hands! The tasting was just as delicious as everything was on wedding day! Our guests/friends/family are still raving about how authentic, flavorful and fresh the food was- George and his team really know their way around the kitchen and Tracy’s services as day-of-coordinator also gave us great peace of mind both leading up to, as well as on the big day. Tracy’s staff was SUPER helpful, attentive, and everyone knew what they were doing at literally ALL times which gave us such peace of mind. Tracy’s boundless knowledge and experience in the industry proved time and again to be valuable throughout the planning process & day-of. My husband, entire family, and I are so very grateful to have found this genuinely amazing team! They say you get what you pay for, and Platinum Party Planners is absolutely worth every penny!!
Jen&Jay M., a month ago
Quick responder
Renegade Outpost 

5.0

  • Starts at $1,500
  • Serves Bayport, NY

Renegade Outpost is a full service event planning and chef services company. We've been in business for 12 years and have been working with Thumbtack/Zola. We have been hired more than 400 times and have 250 5-star reviews. We offer logistical services as well as day/of coordination and securing rentals. Our "rolodex" includes many of the best vendors for all your event needs. Making your job easier is our highest priority. Wonderful food always begins with amazing ingredients, especially produce. We source directly from local farmers, we work with an organic butcher, a wild fish monger and importers of select cheese and specialty products.

Awarded Best of Zola
Ellen did a great job. I will hire her again. She is very responsive, provides many choices and delivers on what she promises. The wait staff where very nice and helpful. Everyon loved the food and commented on it. My home was left spotless after the party. There were no surprises.
Susan, 10 months ago
TrendlineTrending
SHMAYLEYS Mobile Events Bar 

5.0

  • Starts at $1,500
  • Serves Bayport, NY

Welcome to Shmayleys Mobile Events Bar, your all-inclusive event experience. We are your top choice for all-in-one event solutions. For a party & partnership to get excited about, inquire within. Event Planning: We specialize in creating memorable events. An inviting experience, bringing your celebration to life. Photo Booth: Capture your memories and all the fun in our photo booth! Dessert + Munchies: We offer an Ice Cream + Desserts Bar, alongside a Sweet and Savory Munchies Bar. Mobile Cocktail: From classic favorites to innovative creations, our bar adds sophistication and excitement to your event.

Awarded Best of Zola
I worked with Hayley at a wedding last summer as a photographer and would definitely recommend her! She was fun to work with and made sure that the couples wishes came true.
Molly Rebscher, 4 years ago
TrendlineTrending
NORR Kitchen 

5.0

  • Starts at $99
  • Serves Bayport, NY

Hi I'm Christiann! My Co-founder and I have owned a successful, 🌟- all platform -5 star 🌟 restaurant & craft bar and am now offering my services in the Southern California region. From full craft bar services, exquisite wine pairings and events, to outdoor experiences and private in home dinner parties, our advanced and highly trained team have you covered. Let’s connect! I can’t wait to bring the 5 star experience to your home or event. Feel free to ask for additional verified reviews, I have dozens. I'm new to this platform : )

I recently had the pleasure of attending a dinner party hosted by Christiann, and it was an exceptional experience from start to finish. The evening began with a delightful cocktail hour featuring delicious appetizers, setting the tone for the rest of the evening. We were then ushered into a cozy, intimate setting for a five-course meal that surpassed all expectations. Christiann's culinary skills were truly impressive; each dish was expertly prepared and showcased fresh, local ingredients. What stood out the most was her attention to detail. From the thoughtfully curated cocktails to the perfectly matched wine pairings, every aspect of the meal was meticulously planned. The atmosphere was warm and inviting, making it easy to relax and enjoy the company. It was evident that Christiann put a lot of thought and effort into ensuring that everyone had a memorable evening. In a city known for its vibrant food scene, Christiann's talent truly shines. Thank you for a truly unforgettable evening!
Grant E., 2 months ago
Quick responder
Just a Nibble NYC 

5.0

  • Starts at $15,000
  • Serves Bayport, NY

Owned and operated by native New Yorkers with over 20 years experience in high end catering. We use fresh, locally-sourced ingredients and are meticulous in our plating and presentation. We know how to cultivate the right atmosphere in any of the city’s spaces. Whether your event is in one of New York’s most beloved and iconic venues, or in your own living room, tell us what you have in mind, and then leave it to us! We know just what to do.

Awarded Best of Zola
Just a Nibble was absolutely fantastic to work with. I looked into a bunch of different catering companies for my wedding, and Nick was the only one who really guided me through the process. It was such a relief. And then there was the food! Totally exquisite. My friends and family are still talking about it. Nick’s staff were so friendly and helpful. They took care of everything and really allowed me to just enjoy the day. Can’t wait to work with them for our next event.
Anna, 7 months ago
TrendlineTrending
Fig & Pig Catering 

5.0

  • Starts at $170
  • Serves Bayport, NY

Fig & Pig continues to be a creative, quality-driven catering company devoted to showcasing seasonal ingredients and producing exceptional, food-focused events. Our team of professionally-trained chefs cook with dedication and pride to create thoughtful meals that are both comforting and modern. We work closely with our clients to build curated menus and distinctive settings that reflect the personality and vision of their event. At Fig & Pig, the service is as important as the food. Our front of house team drives the success of each event and they take very seriously, the needs of our guests.

Cannot recommend Holly and Tammy from Fig and Pig enough. For starters food often is an after thought in weddings it’s like you need it but you don’t remember it. We wanted the food to be an experience for our guests and they did not disappoint. No matter what dish you got it was superb. They worked with us to make a special treat for the Cocktail hour and people are still coming to me weeks later saying how brilliant that was. They worked with my dietary restrictions and made the process seamless.
Claire and H., a year ago
TrendlineTrending
That Girl Can Cook NYC 

5.0

  • Starts at $5,000
  • Serves Bayport, NY

Bringing bold flavors and unforgettable experiences to your table, *That Girl Can Cook Catering* is all about crafting mouthwatering dishes that turn every event into a feast to remember. Whether it’s an intimate gathering or a grand celebration, we specialize in personalized menus that reflect your unique taste and style.Our goal is to give the client the best service in all aspects. Chef Renee cooks with love, and she sources the freshest ingredients for artfully plated creations, every dish is made with love, passion, and a dash of flair. She enjoys creating menus for her clients that will make them happy.

I had the chance to work with Renee at one of my client's engagement party where she managed the bar and food service for a big swanky summer barbeque. The setup was smooth, her team was incredibly competent, and the bar was a major hit with the guests. While the food for this particular event was casual picnic fare, everything was served efficiently and on time. I've also had the pleasure of trying Renee's hors d'oeuvres at other events, and they were absolutely delicious - she's clearly a talented chef with a great sense for elevated flavors. Her professionalism and ability to manager large crowd really stood out.
Patricia, 6 months ago
TrendlineTrending
La Mila Catering & Events 

5.0

  • Starts at $75
  • Serves Bayport, NY

Starting their careers in the restaurant and food industry, Elie & Heidi Hanna decided to utilize their unique experiences and create their own vision of a full service event company. La Mila is named after their daughter, Milana, who provides them with limitless inspiration and motivation.

Awarded Best of Zola
As a classically trained chef, I hope my review of La Mila inspires anyone doing their “homework” to earn an A — for themselves, especially their guests. I’ve been to many weddings, and the food served is often an edible afterthought. How many times, when leaving a wedding, were you asked, “What did you think about the food?” — and you replied with shrugged shoulders, “Eh, it was okay.” That is not the case with La Mila. A huge shoutout and thank you to Sandy, who was able to pull together a phenomenal menu all in a very timely timeline. Sandy was honest, upfront, and available around our busy work schedule. The day before and the day of, Sandy was there to help with setup — from the big asks, like helping move furniture, to the small tasks—like lighting lanterns and ensuring no glass of champagne for our toast was served empty! Given our wedding took place at our home, we thoroughly appreciated Sandy staying late to clean the kitchen, empty overflowing garbage, and make sure our home was not a war zone when we woke up the next morning! Elie’s execution of our menu was stellar. As a classically trained chef, I was thoroughly impressed by the well-run machine Elie could create within our garage, the makeshift kitchen for the event. It rained on our wedding day, and we were blessed with a beautiful, vivid rainbow—right before dinner service. This blessing brought all our guests outside for 30 minutes—right before dinner. A major wrench in the moment-by-moment timeline. I know how this, for many chefs, can be a disruptive, unexpected delay—but Elie did not miss a beat. All of our guests raved about the food—notably friends who I graduated with from the Culinary Institute of America. One thing I learned in culinary school is that you “eat with your eyes first.” Simply put, Heidi’s presentation skills are on point! Her attention to detail in creating beautiful food displays, notably for our cocktail hour, showed the care, thought and love we wanted our guests to feel. Sandy, Elie, and Heidi may be the stars of La Mila’s show—but the success of our wedding would not have been possible without their hard-working and friendly staff. One of the elements that sold us on choosing La Mila, was their well-stocked arsenal of kitchen equipment they brought on site. (Most caterers require you rent equipment separately, which is not only more expensive, but introduces a whole new dimension of moving parts.) La Mila was also able to include chinaware, silverware, and the majority of our glassware! They even included soft drinks, water, condiments, cocktail napkins, etc. — all of this, and they still came in under what we were quoted by other caterers. Thank you, Sandy, Elie, Heidi, and the entire La Mila Catering & Events team, for making our wedding day what it was. Your talent, professionalism, and experience were felt by everyone who took part in our special day.
Jordan R. S., a year ago
Quick responder
Glad Mouf 

5.0

  • Starts at $2,000
  • Serves Bayport, NY

Glad Mouf BBQ – Unforgettable Flavor for Your Special Day At Glad Mouf BBQ, we believe every wedding deserves unforgettable food that brings people together. We specialize in craft barbecue with a gourmet twist, featuring the world’s most tender smoked oxtails, melt-in-your-mouth brisket, juicy smoked chicken, brisket tacos —all paired with our legendary sauces. We offer catering with a choice of station-style service with pre-portioned servings or a buffet. Enjoy a special rate of $50 per person for 100+ guests or $75 per person with a 50-guest minimum. Our customizable menu allows you to create the perfect meal for your wedding vision.

Our experience with Glad Mouf catering was fantastic from start to finish. Amir, the owner, had a fun and detailed communication style that made the planning process easy and enjoyable. His team was incredibly professional, delivering flavorful cuisine that wowed our guests. The menu options were unique and creative, and the pricing was very affordable, providing great value. Most importantly, they were punctual and easy to work with on the day of our wedding, ensuring everything ran smoothly so we could focus on celebrating our special day. We highly recommend Glad Mouf for any couple looking for a catering company that combines quality, creativity, and excellent customer service.
Arrielle, 8 months ago
Quick responder
Marlow Events 

5.0

  • Starts at $16
  • Serves Bayport, NY

Marlow Events offers full service catering from the Marlow Collective, a group of New York hospitality brands including the restaurants Borgo, Diner, Marlow & Sons, Roman’s, Achilles Heel, as well as Marlow & Daughters, She Wolf Bakery, and Stranger Wines.

From start to finish, working with Marlow Events was a dream! Their team was so lovely and made sure we got our dream menu. We're still hearing back from our guests about how delicious everything was. And oh my gosh - that wedding cake! So good.
Hannah and M., 3 years ago
Dish Food & Events 

5.0

  • Starts at $150 per person
  • Serves Bayport, NY

Dish Food & Events is an award-winning, full-service catering and events company serving all of New York City and The Hamptons for over 15 years. Recognized for our warm hospitality and delicious food, Dish creates remarkable weddings, social gatherings, and corporate events. What truly differentiates Dish is our diverse team. We are committed to creating an awesome place to work while taking great care of each other, our partners and our guests.

Working with Evalyn, Cortney, and the team at Dish was a truly incomparable experience! I had the pleasure of getting to know Dish a few years back at my first job and had told my contact at the time, Bonnie, that I would definitely be back when it was time for me to host my big event - my wedding. After reconnecting with the Dish team, in particular speaking with Evalyn, we couldn't have felt more confident that it was the right fit for our big day. From the personalized menu, to the in house tasting, and the amazing day of coordinator, Cortney, the most important and expensive party we ever threw (and likely ever will) was in the best hands. When any changes or adjustments came up the team was eager to help make our vision come to life. A few weeks before when I wanted to do another itinerary run through, Cortney, was not just game, but so enthusiastic and supportive. As small things came up day of, Evalyn and Cortney were on it and as we were packing up, the whole Dish team helped us pack up and carry out our numerous flower arrangements. We truly couldn't have pulled this off without Dish and are so grateful for their partnership. Thank you, Dish!
Sarah C., 10 months ago
TrendlineTrending
ONTHEMARC Events 

5.0

  • Serves Bayport, NY

ONTHEMARC is a contemporary, full-service caterer with extensive experience in off-site catered events. The culinary experience is at the heart of everything we do. We handle every detail to bring your vision to life —from custom menus and logistics to staffing and artful presentation—creating an event where you and your guests feel truly celebrated.

ONTHEMARC Catered Events was an incredible choice for our wedding catering. From our first call, their team was quick, attentive, and articulate in addressing all of our questions and requests. On the day of, their execution was flawless - the passed hors d'oeuvres were delicious, the burrata salad was scrumptious, and the filet and scallop entrée was out of this world. The entire staff was so friendly and helpful, and we received countless compliments from our guests on the incredible food and seamless service. There were no lines at the bar, and everyone was smiling and so lovely throughout the entire event. We are so grateful to ONTHEMARC for helping make our special day absolutely perfect.
Emily E., a year ago
GemHidden gem
Sweet Basil Catering 

5.0

  • Starts at $10,000
  • Serves Bayport, NY

We're a woman-owned full-service company established in 2008 and known for seasonal food, beautiful presentation and top-notch service. Our style is "down-to-earth luxury". And our goal is to give our clients an elevated food experience with warm, NEVER stuffy service :) We focus on using seasonal ingredients and present our food with an eye for design. We love to create menus for our couples that reflect their personal tastes.

Awarded Best of Zola
I am a florist in Great Neck, NY and had a chance to decorate for one of my friend’s baby shower. I met Sweet basil first time there and we all really enjoyed working with them! They had the best team-work and i could feel there is a respect each others. It is rare to meet ppl like that kind of attitudes and we really enjoyed the vibe! 100% recommended
Alexis, 6 years ago
Quick responder
Micromony 

5.0

  • Starts at $2,000
  • Serves Bayport, NY

Micromony is a team of individuals specializing in smaller events. We have heard often that the bigger companies price themselves out of possibility with the smaller events so we have decided to create a company that is made just for you. We offer personal chef services for any events under 30 people and can accommodate larger events within a certain geographic range.

Micromony was an excellent wedding caterer for our special day. As quick responders, they listened to our needs and acted on them, providing us with more options and cooking on site. Their customized menu featured delicious Filipino cuisine that our guests raved about. The attention to detail and willingness to accommodate our requests made Micromony a fantastic value and a key contributor to making our wedding day perfect.
Emily, 2 days ago
Green Cart Catering 

5.0

  • Starts at $52
  • Serves Bayport, NY

Green Cart Catering was founded on the desire to do two things: One, to provide healthy & ethical cuisine. And two, to provide event hosts, committed to healthy & ethical eating, the ability to stay true to their values while still providing their guests an outstanding culinary experience! Our 100% plant- based menus will impress everyone and leave no one wanting! Behind our great food is over 30 years’ experience in hospitality services. So, Green Cart Catering can provide you with not only great food, but complete event services, as well!

As a vendor of rental equipment, we've watched Green Cart Catering grow from the early days of the pandemic and mature into a well-managed off-premise caterer. From our vantage point we know the company is well-managed, organized, and committed to delivering great service.
David VanDenburgh, 10 months ago
Mise en Graze 

5.0

  • Serves Bayport, NY

Mise en Graze is a luxury grazing company specializing in artfully curated boards and show-stopping grazing tables that elevate every celebration. With a focus on seasonal ingredients, elegant presentation, and personalized service, we bring The Art of Elevated Grazing to weddings, showers, engagement parties, and more. Founded by Lisa Valverde Mise en Graze was created to turn everyday entertaining into unforgettable experiences. From intimate gatherings to large-scale receptions, each table is a custom culinary centerpiece—designed to wow your guests and reflect your unique style.

Mise en Graze was an absolute dream to work with for our event needs. From the very first interaction, Lisa and her team showcased a visionary and collaborative communication style, truly partnering with us to create the most spectacular charcuterie display we've ever seen. Their attention to detail and artistry resulted in a culinary work of art that added so much magic to our evening. Lisa was able to take our initial brief and elevate it to a level we couldn't have imagined, delivering a final product that exceeded our wildest expectations. The Mise en Graze team were an absolute delight throughout the entire process, and we are so grateful for the role they played in making our event truly unforgettable.
Lavinia, 5 months ago
Quick responder
The Lily’s experience 

5.0

  • Starts at $30
  • Serves Bayport, NY
  • Offer

Welcome to The Lily's Experience Bartending & Catering Service At The Lily's Experience, we create unique moments through exclusive bartending and catering services. We specialize in offering a sophisticated, personalized, and worry-free experience, making every event simply unforgettable. With professional bartenders, tailored culinary offerings, and impeccable service, we guarantee: Signature cocktails and stylish classics Menus designed for every occasion Punctuality, elegance, and professionalism Trust us to elevate your celebration. Book today and experience. The Lily's Experience.

WE HIRED THE LILYS EXPERIENCE, FOR OUR EVENT AND COULDNT BE HAPPIER. THE MOBILE BARTENDER SETUP WAS STYLISH AND PROFESSIONAL, AND THE DRINKS WERE ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS. THE BARTENDER WAS FRIENDLY, ATTENTIVE AND MADA SURE EVERYONE HAD A GREAT TIME. EVERYTHING RAN SMOOTHLY, FROM THE PRESENTATION TO THE SERVICE. I HIGHLY RECOMMEND THEM IF YOU ARE LOOKING TO ELEVATE YOUR PARTY OR SPECIAL OCCASION!!!!
bel e., a month ago
Quick responder
Notre Ferme 

5.0

  • Serves Bayport, NY

Michelin star sober chef creating experiences through food sourcing food all from local farmers. Showcasing seasonality and community. I bring their products to life in the most honest way possible—doing the bare minimum to each ingredient to preserve its authenticity and integrity. I believe it’s just as much my job to educate my clients about the ingredients I use—where they’re from and how they’re cultivated—as it is to create delicious meals.

Allyson and her team are simply the best. Notre Fêrme catered our wedding (May ‘25) and to this day a ton of our guests still rave about the food and service! We cannot recommend them enough.
Zach G., a month ago
TrendlineTrending
Hudson Table 

5.0

  • Serves Bayport, NY

Hudson Table is an interactive culinary studio and event space specializing in customized seasonal catering, hands-on cooking events, chef's tables, virtual events, and more! We currently have locations in Hoboken, Philadelphia, and Brooklyn, and service the surrounding areas.

Hosted a small party here successfully and during COVID -- not easy -- but they were extremely safe and thorough. Excellent food and service. Highly recommend!
Jennifer Bunce-Timmons, 5 years ago

Location flexible? Discover caterers near Bayport, NY