The Best Wedding Cake Bakeries in Indiana

The Best Wedding Cake Bakeries in Indiana

How do we sort results, including Sponsored Ads and personalized results?


56 Wedding Cakes & Desserts in Indiana

Quick responder
Tay’s Sweet Shop 

4.5

Noblesville, IN
  • Serves Indiana

Bringing my passion to life, I specialize in made-from-scratch desserts. I’m a home-based Vendor in Noblesville, IN where small businesses are the heart of our community! I opened in 2017 as part time and took it on full time during the pandemic, after having my daughter.

Awarded Best of Zola
Tay's Sweet Shop was an absolute delight to work with for our wedding. Their communication was quick, professional, and friendly from the very first interaction. The quality of their work was simply elegant, with a sweet and beautiful cake that was the centerpiece of our dessert table. The lemon cake was delicious and a big hit with our guests. Tay's attention to detail ensured our cake was picture perfect and truly captured the spirit of our special day. We couldn't have asked for a better vendor to bring our wedding vision to life.
Rebecca L., 4 months ago
Quick responder
Sis And Me Bakery 

5.0

Nappanee, IN
  • Starts at $36
  • Serves Indiana

My sister and I started this bakery together to share our love and talents with others. We first learned from our Grandma that taught us both growing up in 4H fair and we went to state many times. People liked our work and loved our cake even more so we started this bakery then in 2017. We would love to help you create a special design just for you for your special day!

Awarded Best of Zola
Sis And Me Bakery was an absolute pleasure to work with for our wedding cakes and desserts. Their communication was always quick, reliable, and easy - they responded to our inquiries promptly and provided helpful guidance throughout the process. The quality of their work surpassed our expectations, with cakes and cookies that were not only incredibly delicious but also beautifully executed. When we showed them an inspiration photo for our tiki-themed groom's cake, they said they had never done anything like it before but were confident they could create it, and the final result was truly amazing. Sis And Me Bakery delivered the cakes right on time and even helped us set them up, including adding the cake flowers we had provided. We were blown away by the incredible value and attention to detail they provided, and our guests raved about how delicious the cakes and cookies were. We highly recommend Sis And Me Bakery for any couple looking for an exceptional wedding dessert experience.
Katharine S., 6 months ago
Quick responder
Cakes By Mindy 

5.0

Milford, OH
  • Starts at $750
  • Serves Indiana

Mindy wants each bride to feel special throughout the whole experience of planning her wedding. She takes time to make sure every detail is perfect and that you will walk into your reception and love your cake! She has over 20 years of experience in the art of cake making and attended Midwest Culinary Insitute in Cincinnati, OH. Please reach out with any questions, she is always happy to help!

Cakes By Mindy provided a spectacular, unique, and gorgeous cake for our wedding. Their communication was fast and amazing, and they made the best cake that people are still raving about. The quality of their work and value was truly exceptional. We were thrilled with how Cakes By Mindy contributed to making our special day so memorable.
Rosie A., 6 months ago
Quick responder
The Basement Bakery 

5.0

Indianapolis, IN
  • Starts at $90
  • Serves Indiana

I am a home baker who specialized in decorated sugar cookies, cakes, and small desserts. I would love to help make your special day magical! I work a full time job and bake on the side with a dream of one day being able to open my own bakery!

Rachel was absolutely amazing! From start to finish, she was professional, responsive, and so easy to work with. She really took the time to listen to my ideas and brought my vision to life perfectly. Not only was our wedding cake stunning to look at, but it also tasted incredible. The dessert table she created was equally beautiful and delicious—every guest raved about it! I’m a very picky person, especially when it comes to carrot cake (one of our chosen flavors), and let me tell you—hers was to die for. Moist, flavorful, and just perfect. She did not disappoint in any way. If you’re looking for someone who truly cares about her craft and her clients, I cannot recommend Rachel enough!
Jade, 6 months ago
TrendlineTrending
Sweet Buckets 

5.0

Florence, KY
  • Starts at $300
  • Serves Indiana

We began as a concession company providing cotton candy at sporting events. In the fall of 2021, we extended our brand by starting our own manufacturing plant. Sweet Buckets was born as an option for customers and businesses to purchase Cotton Candy and Gourmet popcorns direct from our company.

Awarded Best of Zola
We had our wedding reception at a brewery and wanted some easy to eat sweet and salty snacks. These popcorn flavors were delicious, they sent us flavors to try before we decided. We chose 4 flavors and they shipped them right to our house. The popcorn buckets had our cute custom labels which they designed for us and looked PERFECT! We had tons of compliments on the popcorn. We ordered plenty and people were grabbing them to take home at the end of the night. A perfect snack after a few beers. Theu were very fast with the samples and the order too!
Lyndsey C., 2 years ago
Quick responder
Sweet Homemade Treats by Shawna and Ashley 

3.7

Indianapolis, IN
  • Starts at $5
  • Serves Indiana

From decadent wedding cakes, perfectly designed for your special day, to birthday cakes bursting with flavor tailored to your loved ones, we take pride in every detail. Not only do we specialize in cakes for weddings, birthdays, and showers, but our offerings extend to a wide array of other delicious sweets that are perfect for any occasion. Whether you're looking for mouthwatering cookies, rich brownies, or luscious pastries, we have something to satisfy every sweet tooth.

Sweet Homemade Treats by Shawna and Ashley provided excellent service and delicious desserts for our wedding. Their communication was fast, easy-going, and in-depth, making the planning process a breeze. The quality of their work was fantastic and provided great value - they were able to create our dream cupcakes within our budget. Our guests raved about the taste and presentation of the desserts, and we were thrilled with the final result. We highly recommend Sweet Homemade Treats for any couple looking for a skilled, affordable, and personable cakes and desserts vendor.
AB, 9 months ago
Quick responder
Maddie About Cake (MAC) 

5.0

Louisville, KY
  • Starts at $66
  • Serves Indiana

Maddie About Cake is a micro-bakery based in Louisville, KY, specializing in French macarons. We help our customers access high-quality French macarons in a variety of unique and unexpected flavor combinations.

I got custom macarons from Maddie About Cake for my wedding favors. As a repeat customer, I already knew the flavors were gonna be amazing! We got red velvet and cinnamon bun. She made them in our wedding colors and also put our names and wedding date on them with custom printing, which was a great personal touch. And all of our guests loved them!
Natalie, 2 years ago
TrendlineTrending
Tastee Treats Louisville 

5.0

Louisville, KY
  • Starts at $400
  • Serves Indiana

I spent 20 years in the corporate world as a Graphic Designer, and baking was something that I always gravitated to when I felt stressed out. During the pandemic, I found myself in the kitchen a lot. I was constantly trying out new recipes and techniques, growing my arsenal of skills, and learning how to batch bake. I also spent that time setting up my business one block at a time, slowly creating a solid foundation of clients like you that enjoy what I make just as much as I do!

Tastee Treats Louisville provided us with a beautiful, delicious wedding cake that exceeded our expectations. The communication with them was easy and responsive, and they truly brought our vision for the cake to life. The cake was not only gorgeous, but also incredibly delicious - we were extremely happy with how it turned out. Tastee Treats went above and beyond to make our special day even more memorable. We highly recommend them to any couple looking for an exceptional wedding cake experience.
Monica S., a year ago
C'est La Vie Cakes 

5.0

South Bend, IN
  • Serves Indiana

At C’est La Vie Cakes, we specialize in truly unique wedding cake creations in the South Bend / Notre Dame/ Southwest Michigan area. ​​​​All of our cakes and cupcakes are handmade with the finest ingredients.

We loved the wedding cake she made for us, we chose pumpkin and snickerdoodle flavorings, showed her an inspiration pic and talked about our amount of people. She delivered! The amount of cake we had was more than enough for how many attendees we had, we should have had some left over. To our surprise, there was not a single slice left! I mean we knew it was good. So we ended up asking for cupcakes to enjoy and she made those for us as well. When in doubt she’s your baker!
Barbara Chitwood, 2 years ago
Quick responder
Yonutz Donuts and Ice Cream- Louisville Ky 

5.0

Louisville, KY
  • Starts at $200
  • Serves Indiana

At Yonutz Donuts and Ice Cream, we take pride in crafting award-winning smashed donuts that elevate every occasion. Our passion for what we do is reflected in our commitment to making each experience seamless and stress-free for our clients. We are honored to be part of your special day and find great joy in witnessing the delight our creations bring. To us, our donuts are not just treats—they are edible art.

If you haven’t tried Yonutz, you’re seriously missing out! Whether it’s their stuffed donuts, over-the-top shakes, or sweet & savory mashups, every bite is a flavor explosion. The team is friendly, the vibe is fun, and everything is totally Instagram-worthy. Perfect for: A weekend treat Surprise snack stop with the kids Or catering your next event — trust me, they’ll steal the show!
Jill O., 3 months ago
GemHidden gem
Classic Cakes 

5.0

Carmel, IN
  • Serves Indiana

Award winning custom cake shop in Carmel, Indiana. We offer complimentary cake tastings which you can book directly online at www.classiccakescarmel.com/book Our bakery has been leading the industry in innovation of cake artistry & business since 1995.

Our lemon raspberry cake was rich and decadent. There were no complaints. We can’t wait to have another occasion to celebrate with a cake from Classic Cakes. Simply amazing.
Emanuel M., 2 years ago
GemHidden gem
Sweets By Millie 

5.0

Louisville, KY
  • Starts at $250
  • Serves Indiana

For over a decade, Sweets by Millie has been providing the highest quality boutique wedding cakes for couples across the Louisville area. We strive to create unique wedding desserts for each client, and help make their special day personalized and perfect!

Sweets By Millie exceeded my expectations as my wedding baker. She was so kind and understanding throughout the entire process. We worked together to create a custom cake and cupcake display that perfectly captured my vision. The two tier cake and variety of cupcake flavors were not only gorgeous but also delicious - my guests couldn't stop raving about them! She was creative, flexible, responsive and a true professional. The quality and attention to detail of her work is amazing, especially considering the value. I would highly recommend Sweets By Millie for any special event where you want sweets that are as beautiful as they are tasty.
Franny H., a year ago
TrendlineTrending
Two Sons Cakery 

5.0

Springville, IN
  • Serves Indiana

We are a certified, appointment-only cake studio located just south of Bloomington, Indiana. With award winning cakes, Two Sons Cakery provides an unforgettable experience by inspiring a culture of pride and customer satisfaction. Creating top quality, imaginative, and delicious baked treats, we make sure to respond positively to the needs of the community. Whether you’re looking for a simple naked cake or something more creative and unique, we’ve got just the thing for you!

We trusted Two Sons Cakery to help us design our wedding cake. From the cake tasting to the delivered product on our wedding day, we couldn’t be more pleased. Amanda is so much fun to work with as her creativity and artistic talent really shine through on her cakes. Our wedding cake was no exception. She knew how to make the design I had in my head come to life in the cake. From a communication stand point, Two Sons Cakery has a high level of professionalism that is very much appreciated when planning a wedding. Response time to questions were answered quickly and communication was always thorough and clear. Our cake was delivered over an hour away and everything looked beautiful! We highly recommend Two Sons Cakery and all they have to offer for any occasion you are planning. You will not be disappointed.
Zach & K., 5 years ago
Bae's Baekery 

5.0

Louisville, KY
  • Serves Indiana

Bae’s Baekery™, LLC began in January 2019 when Abigail Mattingly was gifted a Kitchen Aid mixer for the holidays. She had baked her entire life, but was allowed to explore more avenues previously unavailable upon receiving the mixer. She was already baking for family and friends throughout the holidays, but began to crank out more products, including cookies, eclairs, bagels, and other pastries, and was advised continuously to begin selling her products.

Bae's Baekery has been my go-to for all our special occasion desserts ever since I first discovered their amazing cookies years ago. The communication with the team is always quick, timely, and very detailed - they make the ordering process a breeze. But the real star is the quality of their work and the taste of their desserts. The attention to detail is phenomenal, and their cakes and pastries are absolutely delish! I'm so thrilled to see Bae's Baekery thriving and I will continue to buy all our special occasion sweets from them. Our wedding day cake was better than I could have imagined!! The cookie butter flavor we chose was just the icing on the cake
Morgan J., a year ago
TrendlineTrending
Sub Zero Nitrogen Ice Cream + 1832 Brew Espresso Bar 
Carmel, IN
  • Starts at $475
  • Serves Indiana

With Sub Zero Ice Cream catering, we give you a simple and delicious way to be the star of the show. Sub Zero provides your guests with a unique, fresh, and delicious option, with an experience they’ll remember and still be talking about for months. Make Your Next Event the Highlight of the Year! Not just a dessert, but an experience.

Quick responder
Simply Sweet Ice Cream Catering. Ice cream only — no cake services” 

5.0

Clinton, TN
  • Starts at $525
  • Serves Indiana

Ice cream only — no cake services” I have a super cute ice cream cart! I would love to be your dedicated server on your special day! Offering over 70 premium ice cream flavors including gluten free, reduced fat/no sugar added, and non dairy addition options! Best selling flavors: Chocolate, Moose Tracks, Cookies and Cream, Green Mint Chip, Strawberry, Vanilla, Cappucino Crunch, and Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough! My business is based in Clinton, TN but serving surrounding counties and states. I am licensed and insured! I look forward to serving you and your guests!

Anita arrived early, served ice cream quickly and efficiently and was great to work with! I had so many compliments of her stand and the flavors. The stand was adorable and blended in so nicely at the wedding. Perfect for a hot day!
Sydney C., a year ago
Quick responder
The Cake Boutique 

5.0

Mattawan, MI
  • Starts at $500
  • Serves Indiana

The Cake Boutique specializes in high end center of attention cakes. We work with each client to create a unique, delicious cake for your special occasion. Beth is an award winning cake artist and professional chocolatier, learning all she can from Melissa Coppel. She is a certified judge, who travels the US teaching and judging sugar art. I was a 2x competitor on Food Network and Food Network Canada, of which I won! I have been published in: The New York Times, Cake Masters Magazine, and more! We would love to be a part of your special day!

Awarded Best of Zola
Beth was fantastic. She asked just the right questions so it was like she could see my vision through my eyes. The cake was perfect and beyond delicious. My guests were raving about it. Beth is phenominal. Don't wait another minute to book her. Run now!
Melissa S., 6 months ago
Quick responder
Delish Cakes 

5.0

Bloomingdale, IL
  • Starts at $30
  • Serves Indiana

Delish Cakes started in 2010 out of Alicia's family home. It quickly outgrew the house and a storefront was born shortly after! Delish Cakes will be 11 years old in August of 2021. Delish Cakes creates custom cakes and sweets for any occasion, and we love to make each order just as special as the clients who order them! Everything is created in small batches and made just for you. We do Cakes, cake pops, custom sugar cookies, sweet tables, cupcakes and more.

We cannot say enough wonderful things about the incredible baker who created my son and daughter-in-law’s wedding cake and the most stunning sweet table trays. Every detail was absolutely perfect. My son is a huge Star Wars fan, and she brought his vision to life in the most beautiful and creative way—one side of the cake was designed especially for my daughter-in-law, elegant and classic, while the other side was a surprise for my son with the perfect Star Wars touch. It was not only gorgeous but truly a work of art. The sweet table trays were equally amazing—beautifully arranged, delicious, and a huge hit with our guests. You could tell how much love, talent, and care she put into every single piece. She went above and beyond for us, and we are so grateful. If you want someone who is passionate, artistic, professional, and incredibly talented, look no further. She made their wedding truly unforgettable.
Kristi K., 10 days ago
The Cakery 

5.0

Dayton, OH
  • Starts at $3
  • Serves Indiana

The Cakery has been a Dayton staple since 1996. The current owners have worked at The Cakery since the early 2000's and love what they do! We know that it is a privilege to be chosen by a couple to be a part of their special day, no matter how big or small it may be. We will work with you to make sure that your dreams and vision come to life! We believe that everyone has the right to celebrate their love and commitment to one another, and we would be honored to be a part of your celebration!

Awarded Best of Zola
We absolutely loved our wedding cake! It was perfect and received rave reviews from the wedding party as well! The cupcakes were delicious and enjoyed by all our guests. We had many extra and had no problem getting people to take some home! The Cakery was easy to work with and everything was executed exactly as discussed. We wanted simple and classy and got just that! The cake and cupcakes were delivered, set up and wedding topper added with complete accuracy. I would definitely recommend The Cakery to anyone planning a wedding or special event!
Teri B., 2 years ago
TrendlineTrending
The Original Rainbow Cone 

5.0

Berwyn, IL
  • Starts at $1,350
  • Serves Indiana

The Original Rainbow Cone has been a staple in Chicago for over 95 years! We serve our signature combination of Chocolate, Strawberry, Palmer House, Pistachio and Orange Sherbet sliced and stacked on a cone. We also offer other flavors upon request. We offer on-site catering with our trucks for outdoor events, and our pop up ice cream social service for indoor events!

My wife and I have always loved Rainbow Cone. Our first date was at their original Beverly location over 13 years ago, and it felt only fitting to have Rainbow Cone present at our wedding reception. From the beginning, John B. and his team were communicative, professional, and great to work with. On the day of the reception the RBC team showed up when they were supposed to and did an amazing job of providing quick and courteous scoop service to our 150 guests. They even went above and beyond and cleaned their area of the reception hall when our caterer dropped the ball and didn't do it themselves (please don't expect them to do this, but just to show they did an amazing job!) Plus, above all of that, the ice cream was just delicious, and initiated many folks into the Rainbow Cone fan club when they got their first taste. Overall, RBC provided a 10/10 experience that we'll always be thankful for and will never forget. We're fans for life. Thanks Rainbow Cone!
Nick S., 4 years ago